Have you noticed your dog losing interest in activities they once enjoyed, like playing with toys, eating their favourite treats, or seeking your attention? This could be a sign of "learned helplessness," a condition where a dog shuts down emotionally and behaviourally due to repeated exposure to unpredictable punishment or negative experiences (Lindsay, 2000).
Learned helplessness can look like depression in dogs, with signs like sleeping excessively, avoiding interaction, and appearing mentally "paralyzed" (Stilwell, 2013; Lindsay, 2000). Understanding the causes and knowing how to help your dog recover can make all the difference in restoring their happiness and well-being.
What Causes Learned Helplessness?
Learned helplessness in dogs is often caused by inconsistent or non-contingent punishment—when a dog cannot predict or understand why they are being punished or how to avoid it (Lindsay, 2000). For example, using a shock collar to stop a dog from jumping can create confusion if the shock isn't delivered at the exact moment of the unwanted behaviour. The dog may become fearful of all greetings, unsure of what actions will trigger a shock.
Imagine a dog that is shocked whenever its paws touch a person. Some days, the shock is given when the paws land on someone; other times, it's delivered when the feet leave the ground, and yet another time, the owner invites the dog to jump up and cuddles without a shock until the dog gets too excited, and then it is shocked. This inconsistency creates a situation where the dog cannot predict when or why the shock will occur, leading to anxiety, fear, and ultimately, learned helplessness (Lindsay, 2000).
When dogs experience such unpredictability and inconsistency, they may stop trying to avoid punishment altogether. In an experiment conducted by Seligman (1972), dogs exposed to inescapable shocks stopped attempting to escape the shocks, accepting the painful experience even when they had the chance to avoid it. This demonstrates the depth of learned helplessness, where dogs feel so overwhelmed that they give up trying to change their situation.
Signs of Learned Helplessness in Dogs
Loss of Interest: Your dog may lose interest in food, toys, and social interactions.
Depression-like Symptoms: Look for excessive sleeping, quietness, or avoidance of activities they once loved.
Fearful Reactions: Your dog may fear any attempt to engage, especially if they associate people or specific situations with negative experiences.
Physical Indicators of Stress: Watch for signs like trembling, tail-tucking, or cowering, which could indicate fear and pain in various contexts where the dog expects a negative outcome (Blackwell and Casey, 2006).
How to Help a Dog Recover from Learned Helplessness
If your dog is showing signs of learned helplessness, the road to recovery can be long, but it is possible with patience, understanding, and positive reinforcement. Here are some steps to help your dog regain confidence and trust:
Rebuild the Relationship
The bond between you and your dog may have been damaged due to the previous use of punishment-based training. Research shows that dogs can associate the discomfort or pain from a shock with their owner (Schilder and van der Borg, 2004). To rebuild trust, focus on positive, rewarding interactions without the use of punishment.
Remove Triggers: Eliminate any situations that might cause fear or anxiety. For example, avoid having visitors or unfamiliar people around until your dog feels more secure (Landsberg, 2018).
Reduce Stress Hormones
Dogs experiencing learned helplessness often have elevated levels of beta-endorphins, natural painkillers that can create a state similar to sedation (Kesling, 2010). Instead of stress-induced endorphins, encourage the release of dopamine, the "feel-good" hormone that provides a natural reward and motivation. You can raise dopamine levels through:
Gentle Activities: Walks, swimming, massage, and playtime can all help increase dopamine levels.
Positive Reinforcement Training: Teach your dog simple commands like "sit" using treats and praise, so they begin to associate positive experiences with you again (Landsberg, 2018).
Address Fear of People
Since learned helplessness often involves fear of people, gradually reintroduce your dog to situations where they feel safe. Use desensitization and counter-conditioning techniques to help them associate people with positive experiences.
Desensitisation: Start by letting your dog see people from a safe distance, offering treats, massages, or other calming activities.
Gradual Exposure: Slowly bring people closer, rewarding your dog for calm behaviour. Eventually, progress to having people interact with your dog, always ensuring positive reinforcement at each step (Stilwell, 2013).
Introduce a Secondary Reinforcer
Using a secondary reinforcer, like a marker word ("yes" or "good") before giving a treat, can help your dog understand that a reward is coming. This can encourage positive behaviour and reduce anxiety (Lindsay, 2000).
Manage Generalized Fear
Once your dog is comfortable with you and familiar people, work on generalizing this comfort to new environments and situations. This involves conditioning your dog to associate various settings and people with positive experiences like food, massage, or playtime (Landsberg, 2018).
Consider Professional Help and Medication
If your dog is having difficulty progressing through these steps, consulting a veterinarian or behaviourist may be helpful. In some cases, anxiety-reducing medication, with a vet's agreement, could support your dog's recovery process (Kesling, 2010).
Recovering from learned helplessness takes time, but with patience, consistency, and a focus on positive reinforcement, you can help your dog regain confidence and enjoy life again. Building trust, reducing stress, and using gentle training methods will help your dog understand that they are safe, loved, and can once again explore the world around them without fear.
Add comment
Comments